Navigating the complexities of workers' compensation can be daunting, especially when it comes to understanding permanent disability benefits. Whether you’re recovering from an injury or helping a loved one through the process, having a clear grasp of what permanent disability benefits entail and how they differ from temporary wage benefits is crucial. This guide aims to break down these differences, explain the qualification criteria, and provide tips to help you maximize your benefits, ensuring you’re well-equipped to handle this challenging time with confidence and clarity.
Temporary Benefits
Temporary benefits are monetary awards given to replace your lost wages while you’re unable to work or working at a reduced capacity due to an injury. It doesn’t matter if you have a broken foot, a sprained ankle, or a torn rotator cuff—the rules are the same. These benefits kick in as soon as your injury forces you to take time off work. However, once you return to work and start earning the same or more than you were before the accident, these benefits stop.
Permanent Benefits
Permanent benefits come into play when your injury is deemed permanent. This determination happens at what’s known as Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI). MMI is reached when doctors conclude that further medical treatment won't improve your condition—you’ve plateaued. At this point, if you still have lasting problems, your injury is classified as permanent, and permanent benefits are considered. Unlike temporary benefits, these are calculated and paid out based on the lasting impact of your injury.
Schedulable Injuries
Schedulable injuries are specific injuries to extremities, including arms, hands, legs, feet, fingers, and toes. Each of these body parts has an assigned value based on a schedule set by law. For instance, if you lose total use of an arm, you’re entitled to a certain number of weeks of workers' compensation benefits. The exact amount you receive depends on the percentage of loss of use determined by your doctor.
Non-Schedulable Injuries
Non-schedulable injuries, on the other hand, involve systemic or core body parts such as the head, neck, and back. These injuries are more complex because they can affect your overall ability to work in different ways. Compensation for non-schedulable injuries considers not just the physical impairment but also how the injury impacts your ability to earn a living. For example, a severe back injury might prevent you from performing any job that requires physical labor, significantly affecting your earning capacity.
Qualifying for permanent disability benefits hinges on a few key factors. First and foremost, your injury must be deemed permanent, meaning you've reached Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI). This is the stage where further medical treatment won’t improve your condition any more than it already has.
Anyone who has a permanent disability resulting from a work-related accident could qualify for these benefits. However, there are circumstances where you might not receive monetary compensation. For instance, if you have a permanent neck or back injury but are back at work earning the same or more than you did before your accident, you may not qualify for additional payments. This is because your injury hasn’t diminished your wage-earning capacity.
In essence, to qualify for permanent disability payments, you need to demonstrate that your injury has a lasting impact on your ability to work and earn. If you're back at your previous salary level or higher, it might be challenging to prove this, but generally, if your injury limits your ability to work or forces you to take a lower-paying job, you should be eligible for some form of compensation.
Schedulable Injuries
For schedulable injuries, benefits are calculated based on a predetermined schedule that assigns a value to each body part. For example, a total loss of use of an arm might entitle you to 312 weeks of compensation, whereas a foot might be worth 205 weeks. The amount you receive is proportional to the percentage of loss of use. So, if you have a 10% loss of use of an arm, you’d receive 31.2 weeks of benefits. These benefits are paid at two-thirds of your gross average weekly wage at the time of your accident, up to a statutory maximum.
Non-Schedulable Injuries
Non-schedulable injuries, such as those affecting the head, neck, or back, are more complex. Here, the benefits are calculated based on the degree of physical impairment and your vocational background. The doctors will assess your physical disability, but the judge will also consider how your injury impacts your ability to work. For example, a person with extensive education and diverse job skills might find it easier to get back to work than someone with limited skills. Thus, the compensation might be adjusted based on how significantly your injury affects your ability to earn a living.
When dealing with multiple injuries, such as an overlapping schedulable and non-schedulable injury, the approach to calculating benefits will depend on which injury is more severe and which method provides better compensation. This ensures you receive the most appropriate benefits for your specific circumstances.
Payment Structure
Receiving permanent disability benefits is different from receiving temporary wage benefits. Temporary benefits are paid out bi-weekly as long as you are out of work or earning less due to your injury. Permanent benefits, however, can vary depending on the type of injury.
Lump-Sum vs. Bi-Weekly Payments
For schedulable injuries, the compensation is usually paid as a lump sum. This means once your permanent disability percentage is determined, you receive a one-time payment based on the value assigned to your specific injury. This lump-sum payment helps you move forward without waiting for bi-weekly checks.
For non-schedulable injuries, the benefits are typically paid out over time in bi-weekly checks, similar to temporary benefits. The judge will determine the duration of these payments based on the severity of your injury and its impact on your ability to work.
Settlements
In some cases, especially with non-schedulable injuries, you might have the option to negotiate a lump-sum settlement, known as a Section 32 settlement. This allows you to receive a portion of your future benefits upfront, providing immediate financial relief. However, it’s important to consider the long-term implications of such settlements and discuss them with your lawyer to ensure it’s the best option for your situation.
Avoiding Fraud and Malingering
One of the biggest mistakes you can make is attempting to exaggerate or fake the severity of your injury, known as malingering. When you go for medical examinations, it’s crucial to give your best effort and be honest about your condition. Doctors are trained to spot inconsistencies, and any sign that you might be faking can severely damage your credibility and your case. Always present your true level of pain and limitation.
Staying Focused on Relevant Injuries
Another common mistake is trying to highlight unrelated injuries during your assessments. If you have a specific injury that is the focus of your case, make sure to discuss it thoroughly with your doctor and during examinations. Trying to bring in other injuries that don’t impact your ability to work as much can dilute the strength of your main claim.
Keeping Accurate Records
It’s essential to keep detailed records of all your medical visits, treatments, and any correspondence related to your injury and claims. Document everything meticulously, especially discrepancies or issues during Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs). Take notes, highlight problems in reports, and communicate these clearly with your attorney. This will help build a stronger case and ensure that any issues are promptly addressed.
Work with a Knowledgeable Workers' Compensation Doctor
Having a good doctor who specializes in workers' compensation is invaluable. Not only will they provide the best possible treatment to help you recover, but they’ll also know how to properly document your condition and progress. This documentation is crucial for your case, as it serves as evidence of your injury and its impact on your life.
Choose an Experienced Attorney
A skilled workers' compensation attorney can make a significant difference in your case. They will know how to present medical evidence effectively, cross-examine insurance company doctors, and navigate the complexities of workers' compensation law. A good attorney ensures that your case is as strong as possible and that you receive the maximum benefits available.
Document IME Experiences
Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs) can be stressful, and often, the reports from these exams can be incomplete or inaccurate. After an IME, take a copy of the report, make detailed notes in the margins about any discrepancies or issues, and share this with your attorney. Your firsthand account can be critical during cross-examination of the IME doctor.
Stay Informed and Involved
Keep yourself informed about the status of your case and actively participate in it. Regularly communicate with your attorney, attend all medical appointments, and ensure all your paperwork is up-to-date. The more involved you are, the more likely you are to catch any errors or omissions that could affect your benefits.
Can Chronic Pain Be a Disability?
Yes, chronic pain can be considered a disability if it significantly impacts your ability to work. While pain is subjective and can vary from person to person, if it prevents you from performing your job duties or reduces your earning capacity, it can be classified as a disabling condition. It’s important to have your chronic pain well-documented by your doctor to support your case.
What Happens if My Job Can’t Accommodate Permanent Restrictions?
If your employer cannot accommodate your permanent restrictions, you might be eligible for additional benefits. This situation often arises when larger employers have strict policies against returning workers with partial disabilities. While it’s not necessarily actionable under workers' compensation law, it could involve employment law issues. Discussing your situation with an attorney specializing in employment law might reveal additional options or protections.
How Are Multiple Injuries Calculated?
When dealing with multiple injuries, such as an ankle and both knees, each injury is evaluated separately based on the workers' compensation schedule. The percentages of disability for each body part are calculated individually and then combined to determine your total benefit. This process ensures that you receive compensation proportional to the overall impact of your injuries on your ability to work.
What If the Injury Is Old but Recently Aggravated at Work?
If you have an old injury that was aggravated by a recent work accident, it can still be compensable. The new work-related aggravation must be documented by a doctor who can apportion the percentage of disability attributable to the old injury versus the new aggravation. This process ensures you are fairly compensated for the impact of the work-related incident.
How Do Permanent Disability Benefits Differ from Temporary Benefits in Terms of Payment?
Temporary benefits are paid bi-weekly while you’re out of work or earning less due to your injury. In contrast, permanent disability benefits for schedulable injuries are usually paid as a lump sum once your level of permanent disability is determined. For non-schedulable injuries, payments are made bi-weekly over a period determined by the judge, based on the severity of your injury and its impact on your earning capacity.
I hope this guide has helped clarify some of the complexities surrounding permanent disability benefits. Navigating workers' compensation can be tough, and you don’t have to do it alone. If you have any questions or need further assistance, feel free to reach out. I’m here to help you understand your rights and ensure you get the benefits you deserve.
You can contact me, Rex Zachofsky, at 212-406-8989. Whether it’s a quick question or you need comprehensive support, don’t hesitate to give me a call. We’ll work together to make sure you’re taken care of every step of the way.
.jpg)
.jpeg)
