The last thing you want to do when settling your Workers' Comp Case is get lowballed. That's why I'm going to break down everything you need to know about maximizing your workers' comp settlement, avoiding low-ball offers, and securing the best possible outcome for your situation.
One of the biggest headaches with workers' comp cases is how often insurance companies try to lowball you with a settlement that’s worth way less than your case deserves.
They do this a lot because the sooner they can get you to settle, the more money they keep. These lowball offers usually show up early on, aimed at getting you to agree before you’ve had a chance to figure out what your case is really worth. The trick is spotting these moves and not jumping at the first offer just because it’s there.
Figuring out what your workers' comp case is really worth can feel like a lot to handle, but there are a few key things to focus on:
These all play a big role in determining the value of your case. For instance, a higher weekly wage can mean a bigger settlement, and solid medical findings from your doctor about your injury can give you a strong foundation for negotiations.
If you’re not sure where to start, check out state resources like your workers' comp board's website—they usually have helpful info on how permanent impairment is calculated. But at the end of the day, the best way to figure out what your case is worth is to have the right legal support. A good lawyer can help you understand the full value of your claim and negotiate to get you what you deserve.
So, you got a settlement offer, and it’s way too low. What happens if you say no?
The good news is, usually, nothing major. Turning down a low offer doesn’t shut things down—it just keeps the negotiations going. Your lawyer will take it from there, going back to the insurance company and pushing for a fairer deal using the details of your case and their legal know-how to make your case for more money.
In fact, sometimes saying no to a low offer can actually work in your favor. It shows the insurance company you’re not going to settle for less than what you deserve, which can put pressure on them to come back with a better offer. It’s just how the negotiation process works.
If it feels like every offer from the insurance company is way too low, don’t stress—it’s not the end of the line. This happens a lot in workers' comp cases.
When the lowball offers just keep coming, you and your lawyer can take the case to court. There, a judge can decide what your claim is really worth. Just the threat of going to court can often make the insurance company take negotiations more seriously since they’d rather avoid the hassle and risk of a trial.
If it comes to it, the court can step in and decide what’s fair. Either way, you’re not stuck with those low offers—there’s always a way to fight for a better outcome.
When it comes to settling your case, good communication—especially with your lawyer—is super important. You might get an offer that looks pretty decent at first, but it’s crucial to talk it over with your lawyer before making any moves. Insurance companies love to toss out a quick first offer hoping you’ll take it, but that doesn’t mean it’s the best deal on the table.
Timing is everything when it comes to settling your case. You don’t want to jump into a settlement before you’ve fully recovered or reached what’s called maximum medical improvement (MMI)—basically, the point where your doctor says your condition is as good as it’s going to get. Settling too soon can mean missing out on what your case is really worth, especially if you end up needing more treatments or even surgery.
That said, waiting too long can have its downsides too. In some cases, it might make sense to settle before going through with a major surgery, especially if you’re unsure about the procedure. If the offer is fair, settling early could let you skip the added medical risks while still getting the money you need.
It’s all about finding the right balance, and that’s where your lawyer comes in. They’ll help you figure out the best timing so you’re in the best position to get the compensation you deserve.
If you need major surgeries, long-term treatments, or something life-changing like an amputation, those things can bump up the potential value of your settlement. How serious your injury is and how much you’re able to recover will both factor into how much compensation you might get.
On the other hand, if a surgery ends up really improving your condition, it could lower the long-term value of your case since your disability might not be as severe anymore. It’s all about how your recovery shapes the bigger picture.
If you know you’ve got surgeries or ongoing treatments coming up, it’s easy to feel like holding off on settling is the right move. After all, the longer your treatment lasts, the more those medical bills and lost wages could add to your final settlement.
But sometimes, it actually makes sense to settle before more treatment—especially if you’re on the fence about going through with it. In some cases, you can work out a fair settlement now, skip the risks that come with more medical procedures, and start moving forward with your life. It’s really about carefully weighing your options and figuring out what’s best for you.
First off, make sure you’ve got a solid workers' comp lawyer in your corner. Having someone who knows the ropes is key to handling the twists and turns of your case and making sure you don’t end up settling for less than you should.
Second, don’t rush it. The first offer you get is usually just a starting point, not the final deal, so take your time before deciding.
And finally, timing is everything. Settling too soon could mean missing out on money you deserve, but dragging it out too long can make the whole process more stressful than it needs to be.
If you’re facing tough settlement decisions, feeling low-balled by the insurance company, or just not sure what your case is worth, I’m here to help.
Feel free to reach out to me, Rex Zachofsky, at 212-406-8989. Whether you have questions, need advice, or want to talk through your options, I’m always happy to have a conversation.
There’s no pressure—just a chance to see how I can help you get the best possible outcome for your situation. Let’s work together to make sure you get the compensation you deserve.
.jpeg)
